Can I Transfer My NHS Pension?

For most NHS staff the answer is short and firm: you cannot transfer your NHS pension out to a personal pension or SIPP. The NHS Pension Scheme is one of the “unfunded” public-sector schemes, and since 2015 the law has closed the door on transferring these to defined contribution arrangements. That may feel restrictive, but the scheme you are being kept in is one of the most valuable retirement benefits available anywhere, so the restriction is arguably protecting something well worth keeping.

Why the NHS scheme can’t be transferred out

The distinction that matters is between “funded” and “unfunded” schemes. A funded scheme holds an invested pot of assets from which a transfer value can be paid. An unfunded scheme, like the NHS, teachers’, armed forces and civil service pensions, holds no such pot; benefits are paid from current contributions and general taxation. Because there is no invested fund to move, and to protect the public finances, the Pension Schemes Act 2015 banned transfers from unfunded public-sector defined benefit schemes to defined contribution schemes from April 2015. Our guide to transferring public-sector pensions sets out which schemes are affected.

Note the important exception: the Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) is a funded public-sector scheme, so it does hold assets and can, in principle, offer a transfer value. If you are in the LGPS rather than the NHS scheme, the rules, and the answer, can be different. Any money-purchase additional voluntary contributions (AVCs) you have paid alongside your NHS pension are also a separate DC pot and may be transferable, even though the core benefit is not.

It is worth knowing why the distinction is drawn so firmly. In a funded scheme, letting a member leave with a transfer value simply moves assets that were already set aside for them. In an unfunded scheme there is no pot to move; paying out a transfer value would mean drawing on public money today to buy a member out of a future promise. Successive governments concluded that allowing this at scale would be both costly and open to abuse, which is why the 2015 ban was drawn so widely across the NHS, teachers’, armed forces, police, firefighters’ and civil service schemes. The restriction is about protecting the taxpayer as much as protecting the member.

What you’d be giving up anyway

Even if a transfer were possible, it would rarely be wise. The NHS pension provides a guaranteed, inflation-linked income for life, with a valuable spouse’s pension and death benefits, and it costs you far less than buying equivalent security on the open market. It is a defined benefit promise of the strongest kind. As with any defined benefit transfer, the general principle is that giving up guaranteed income for a pot exposed to investment risk seldom improves your position.

If your reason for wanting to transfer is flexibility, access to a tax-free lump sum, or the ability to vary your income, it is worth remembering that the NHS scheme already offers some of this within its own rules. Members can typically take a tax-free lump sum by commuting part of the pension, choose an earlier or later retirement date with the benefits adjusted accordingly, and in some cases draw benefits while continuing to work. In other words, several of the freedoms people imagine they can only get by transferring out are available inside the scheme, without giving up the underlying guarantee. Checking what your section of the scheme actually permits often removes the impulse to leave it in the first place.

There is a related trap to be aware of. Because members cannot access a cash transfer value, unregulated introducers sometimes target NHS and other public-sector staff with schemes that promise a way to “release” or “unlock” the pension. These are almost always pension scams. If anyone suggests they can free up cash from an unfunded public-sector pension, treat it as a warning sign and walk away. This is information, not personal advice. If you hold a mix of pensions, say an NHS pension plus private pots from other work, Vetted Wealth’s free service can match you with independently vetted, FCA-regulated pension transfer specialists to help you plan around the parts you can and cannot move.

Related questions